Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Saturday, April 20, 2019 09:25:55 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Killing a burglar in self-defence : UK Law

By
25th-Aug-2018       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Barrister M. A. Muid Khan :
Prologue
"…HOMEOWNERS can defend themselves against raiders who break into their house…" (Justice Secretary David Gauke, 6th April 2018, London, UK)
In the wake of the recent case where a pensioner who was arrested for murder over the fatal stabbing of an intruder in his home, and later on released by Police, question arises if a homeowner kills a burglar acting in self defence, in the heat of the moment, is there any self-defence available to him in law to justify his action?  
In my opinion, under the current law, the answer is that homeowner may still have a defence.  In accordance with the guidance published by the Crown Prosecution Service guidance, people are not expected to make "fine judgments" in the heat of the moment.
Burglary
Burglary is a criminal offence. It is defined by s 9 of the Theft Act 1968 (TA 1968) which provides for two different variants of the offence. An individual will be guilty of burglary if: they enter any building or part of a building as a trespasser with intent to steal, inflict grievous bodily harm or do unlawful damage to the building or anything in it; or having entered a building or part of a building as a trespasser, an individual attempts to steal anything in the building or inflicts or attempts to inflict grievous bodily harm on any person in the building.
Sentence
Section 9 of TA 1968, which provides the maximum sentence that someone convicted of burglary will receive is: 14 years - where the offence was committed in respect of a building which is a dwelling & 10 years - where the offence was committed in relation to any other buildings.
Despite having this strict punishment, the incidents of burglaries are increasing at an alarming level in the UK especially in East London.   
On 27th July 2018, Police were again called at 03:39hrs on Friday, following reports of a burglary at Sidney Street, East London. Officers attended and established that a group of men had forced entry to the property before demanding cash and gold from the occupants. The suspects, believed to be up to eight males, grabbed the occupants and threatened them with weapons, including a knife and machetes, before making off with a quantity of items.  In another incident, on 1st August 2018, another burglary took place at Jalalabad Law Associate's Office in Whitechapel High Street. The burglars broke through the window, damaged the office tables, chairs, file of papers & walked free.
Few weeks before, another burglary took place at Kalam Solicitors Office on Whitechapel High Street. Burglars broke through the front door at the middle of the night, damaged valuable items, furniture and displaced file of papers and escaped with valuable items.
In all these incidents, burglars walked away free leaving the owners of these premises to suffer with distress and worries for future possible attacks by burglars. Question arises, would homeowner seat idle and do nothing when their house is attacked by burglars? Or Do they have to wait to be attacked before defending themselves in their home?
Therefore in this article an attempt would be made to establish whether home owner would be protected by law even if they kill a burglar at the heat of the moment in the light of some famous incidents and cases?
Richard Osborn-Brooks case
On 6th April 2018, Metropolitan Police said that they will not press charges against Richard Osborn-Brooks, 78, a pensioner who was arrested for murder over the fatal stabbing of an intruder in his home. Two burglars broke through his door into home at 12.45am, where he lived with his wife. One of the burglars tried to attack him with a screwdriver.   
He stabbed to one of the intruders with a knife, in the heat of the moment who later died at a Hospital. Police arrested the home owner for stabbing the burglar. Later Police released him and told him that they will not press any charge against him over the burglar's death.
Justice Secretary David Gauke also pledges to protect homeowners after this case was published in the newspaper and public opinion forced the Police drop charges against the pensioner. His case has again focused attention on what you can and can't do if an intruder comes into your home.
It is to be noted that the law in this area was change in 2013 came after a farmer Tony Martin was convicted of murder in 2000 for shooting dead a teenage burglar.
It prompted more than ten years of calls for greater legal protection for people who took violent action against intruders in their own home.
Denby Collins's case
In January 2016 the High Court ruled on what had effectively become a test case, brought by the father of alleged intruder Denby Collins, who had been left in a coma after being confronted by a homeowner who put him in a headlock. The judges decided against Mr Collins by ruling that the 2013 rule change did not breach Article 2 (1) of the European Convention on Human Rights which protects the right to respect for life.
Omari Roberts case
In March 2009 builder Omari Roberts 23, 23, killed 17-year-old burglar Tyler Juett following a struggle after he found the teenager and a 14-year-old accomplice in his mother's house in Basford, Nottinghamshire. Juett died of stab wounds.
Mr Roberts was charged with murder, but before the trial could go ahead, the prosecution dropped the case in April 2010, effectively withdrawing its claim that the apprentice builder had acted with "excessive and gratuitous force." It was therefore accepted that Roberts had been acting in legitimate self-defence.
Peter Flanagan's case
In another case, in June 2011 Peter Flanagan 59, was arrested on suspicion of murder after four masked men broke into his home and John Bennell, 27, ended up dying from a stab wound to the chest. Mr Flanagan was put on police bail, but in July 2011, the chief crown prosecutor for the north-west, ruled he had acted in self-defence and should face no further action. In explaining his decision, Mr Afzal said Mr Flanagan had been confronted by a group of intruders, one of whom was armed with a machete.
Mr Afzal said: "I am satisfied that Peter Flanagan acted in self-defence after being woken by noises in his house shortly before midnight. He was confronted by intruders, one of whom was armed with a machete. People are entitled to use reasonable force in self-defence to defend themselves, their family and their property."
CPS Guidance for homeowners
On 4th April 2018, the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) has outlined where you stand when faced with in intruder and how it will be dealt with by police.
CPS guidance confirms that if a homeowner kills a burglar at the moment under certain circumstances where he/she was engaging in what the law regards as legitimate self-defence, then he/she will face no prosecution for killing that burglar.
The legitimacy of that self-defence relies in part on the long-established common law right of honest citizens to use "reasonable force" to protect themselves. The Criminal Law Act 1967 also encoded a similar "reasonable force" defence for actions taken to prevent crime.
'Reasonable' force under law
The Government Legal Department also published a policy on their webpage regarding the "reasonable force against intruders" and confirmed that you can use reasonable force to protect yourself or others if a crime is taking place inside your home.
This means you can be to protect yourself 'in the heat of the moment' - this includes using an object as a weapon. You are also allowed to stop an intruder running off - for example by tackling them to the ground.
Government 'sympathises' with break-in victims and reassures people they can act in self-defence if they fear their life is in danger
The law has said that "reasonable" should be assessed in the context of the danger that you honestly believed you were facing - not the danger you were actually facing.
Therefore, when a burglar unlawfully enters into the homeowner's house with an intent to steal, inflict grievous bodily harm or do unlawful damage to the building or anything in it; or having entered a building or part of a building as a trespasser, attempts to steal anything in the building or inflicts or attempts to inflict grievous bodily harm on any person in the building; and at the heat of that moment if a homeowner kills that burglar under legitimate self-defence, he/she will not face any prosecution for killing that burglar.
Epilogue
The government accepted that in the heat of the moment people might over-react and do something that on calm reflection is seen to have been disproportionate. Even if a homeowner kills a burglar at the moment under certain circumstances where he/she was engaging in what the law regards as legitimate self-defence, then he/she will face no prosecution for killing that burglar.
Hence in 2013, for people facing intruders in their own home, the government further relaxed the reasonable force requirements by introducing the so-called "householder defence." The Crime and Court Act 2013 stated that if you were in your own home, you only had to prove that the force you used in self-defence was not "grossly disproportionate.
The government has firmly put the law on the side of the homeowners, the householders and the family to prevent the burglars enter into their property unlawfully and without any permission. We must stand shoulder to shoulder to protect our houses from the hands of the burglars and use reasonable force against them instead of seating idle and do nothing when our house is attacked by them. We also don't have to wait to be attacked before defending ourselves in our homes against those criminal intruders.
(The writer is a Barrister of the Honourable Society of Lincoln's Inn, Chartered Legal Executive Lawyer of CILEX. In 2016, he won CILEX President AWARD. He was declared as the Best Human Rights Lawyer of England & Wales by Bar Council, Law Society & CILEX. He can be contacted at barristermuid@yahoo.co.uk ).

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Football »

FIFA backs English players' social media boycott over racism


AP, England :FIFA is backing a 24-hour social media boycott by professional players in England in a protest against racial abuse and revealed plans for a new global campaign to eradicate discrimination in soccer.Following a series of high-profile cases in recent weeks, the Professional Footballers' Association has gathered support from ...

International »

US President Trump declares victory on Mueller report D-Day


President Donald Trump, backed by his attorney general, declared himself fully vindicated on Thursday in the investigation into Russian election meddling and alleged collusion with his campaign - even before the American people and lawmakers see the full probe report."Game Over," Trump tweeted, using a "Game of Thrones" style montage ...

Entertainment »

Shanta Jahan in Australia for hosting


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Shanta Jahan is a popular host of present time. Though she acts sometimes but always feels comfortable to present herself as a host to all. For the first time Shanta went to Australia to host a show. She left Dhaka at night on April 18. Today is ...

Editorial »

One is punished for another's sin!


LOCAL media reported that a day labourer was allegedly sent to jail on Wednesday for not paying electricity bill of Tk 4007, even though his house at Mochagora village in Muradnagar upazila in Cumilla district had no electrical line. On Thursday evening, Chief Judicial Magistrate granted him bail after hearing ...

Cricket »

Sri Lanka dump Chandimal, bring back Thirimanne for World Cup


AFP, Colombo :Sri Lanka Thursday dumped established stars including former captain Dinesh Chandimal to hand batsman Lahiru Thirimanne and leg-spinner Jeffrey Vandersay a place in their World Cup squad.Chandimal, who was one-day captain until last October, wicketkeeper-batsman Niroshan Dickwella, off-spinner Akila Dananjaya, openers Danushka Gunathilaka and Upul Tharanga were all ...

Cricket »

Senior players need to take the responsibility: Faruk Ahmed


Former chief selector Faruk Ahmed insisted on the performance of the senior players, stating that they need to take the onus if Bangladesh want to do well in the upcoming ICC Cricket World Cup.According to Faruk, the condition should give Bangladesh a confidence, given that they stormed into the semifinal ...

Entertainment »

Mehazabien’s Boishakhi works create viewers’ attention


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :For the last few years, Mehazabien Chowdhury established her strong position in media by virtue of her acting quality and skill. She is now getting positive response for acting in two Boishakhi plays. Afran Nisho was her co-actor in these two plays - Tom & Jerry and ...

International »

Turkish opposition takes control of Istanbul, re-run appeal still pending


Reuters, Istanbul :Turkey's main opposition candidate took office as Istanbul mayor on Wednesday after a stunning victory over President Tayyip Erdogan's AK Party, but the new head of the country's largest city still faces an appeal for the vote to be re-run.The final result of the March 31 local elections ...

Editorial »

Power politics in Egypt


A HUGE majority of Egypt's MPs on April 16 approved constitutional amendments to allow President Abdel-Fattah al-Sisi in power until 2030. The amendments were initially introduced in February, however after lengthy debates and discussions favouring the Egyptian society it was updated earlier this week. "The president's current term shall expire ...

Football »

Iniesta's J-League club Kobe part ways with coach Lillo


AFP, Tokyo :Barcelona legend Andres Iniesta's Vissel Kobe have terminated the contract of manager Juan Manuel Lillo following a poor run of results, the Japanese club said on Wednesday.The 53-year-old former Real Sociedad and Zaragoza boss won just two of six games since taking charge last October as star-studded Vissel ...

International »

US waging 'financial war' against Palestinians


AP, Ramallah, West Bank :The new Palestinian prime minister on Tuesday accused the United States of declaring "financial war" on his people and said an American peace plan purported to be in the works will be "born dead."In his first interview with international media since taking office over the weekend, ...

City »

Various organisations formed a human chain in front of Jatiya Press Club on Wednesday marking the International Krishok Sangram Dibash-2019.


Entertainment »

Priya Bapat to take up a web series


Web Series are surely the in thing nowadays and so many actors, irrespective of their stardom, are being seen in them. Marathi superstar Priya Bapat has also bagged a web series called City Of Dreams. Sharing her experience of being part of the series, she says, “Web series are now ...

Editorial »

Urgent steps needed to check outbreak of diarrhoea


AT the advent of summer this year, the number of diarrhoea patients has already crossed the recent records. International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh, and the other city hospitals are struggling to tackle the surge in diarrhoea patients. The diarrhoea patients admitted to the ICDDR,B has crossed the number ...

Cricket »

Tearful Taskin vows to make a strong comeback


Fast bowler Taskin Ahmed vowed to make a strong comeback after being snubbed from the 15-member World Cup squad, announced by the Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) on Tuesday.Chocked with emotions as tears were rolling down from his cheek Taskin shared his disappointments with media."Its' ok just pray for me," Taskin ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news