Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Monday, June 17, 2019 06:10:33 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Commentary

Judgement has held out a beacon of hope for democracy and freedom

photo by

By MAINUL HOSEIN
07th-May-2016       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

The High Court Division of the Supreme Court by declaring unconstitutional the amendment by which the parliament claimed the power of punishing the judges of the Supreme Court has asserted the position of the Supreme Court as the guardian of the Constitution.A Special Bench of the High Court Division presided by Mr Justice Moyeenul Islam Chowdhury delivered the judgement while deciding on a writ petition challenging the constitutionality  of the amendment. The two other judges are Mr Justice Dr Quazi Reza-Ul Hoque and Mr Justice Md Ashraful Kamal.Despite the government's absolute control over the controversial parliament the government was advised to take the most audacious decision to change the Constitution once again, this time to deny the Supreme Court its independence. Nothing is surer for destroying democracy than to deny the judiciary independence.Their Lordships observed that to remove a judge byparliament is an accident in history but in most Commonwealth Countries the judges are not removed by the parliament. Their Lordships were highly critical of Article 70 of the Constitution by which a member of the parliament loses his/her seat if he/she votes against  the party line.What the Special Bench has found most inconsistent with the Constitution is that the judges of the highest court shall be at the mercy of MPs.What should be clear to all is that the 16th amendment to the Constitution was brought in to keep the supreme judiciary under threat of impeachment and the government free to do any illegality unrestrained by any constitutional constraint. The expectation was that the Supreme Court judges shall remain ready to oblige the Prime Minister right or wrong otherwise live under the threat of impeachment hanging over them. Previously, the government amended the Constitution to hold general election by not resigning. As a result elections have become meaningless for the people to change the government.At that time the government took advantage of a one-judge majority judgement of the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court which permitted the government not to resign for holding the general election. The eminent lawyers of the country advised the court against the propriety of such decision. Three out of four judges dissented. But to no avail.There is no precedent that under the parliamentary system general elections are held without first dissolving the parliament and declaring the parliamentary seats vacant. This judgement will remain a black spot in the history of our democratic struggle until the judgement is revisited for more careful scrutiny.In effect this judgement of the Supreme Court under the then Chief Justice his Lordship Mr Justice ABM Khairul Haque, who cast the deciding majority vote, disenfranchised the people. Elections have become mostly a violent exercise and there is no way to ensure fair elections. Lives are lost for the greedy struggle of power of others. The election as a democratic institution has been choked to death.Unfortunately, the Constitution was changed again to destroy another vital democratic institution, the guardian of the Constitution, namely, the Supreme Court itself. Some elements somewhere issuing the guidelines for our self-destruction and we are not careful.If the present amendment prevailed the Prime Minister would have all the powers of controlling the government, the parliament as well as the judiciary. To make this to happen is to destroy the democratic Constitution, the guarantees of fundamental rights and the rule of law. The all powerful Prime Minister will be target of all powerful enemies.The judiciary without independence is no judiciary and becomes part of the government administration. The judges will be in all intend and purposes the government officials. We have only to look at such judiciary in socialist countries.In practice nowhere under one-house parliament which is controlled by the government the parliament claims the power of impeaching judges of the highest court. Only where the parliament consists of two houses, as in Britain, House of Commons and House of Lords, it is relied with the power of impeachment of judges with sufficient checks and balances. There is no fear that the wishes of the few will prevail against command of the people.It is of no help to forget that the sovereign people in their wisdom did not trust the government or the elected parliament with the responsibility of safeguarding the people's Constitution. On the contrary they are required to take the oath of office pledging to abide by the Constitution.By not yielding to the power assumed by the parliament  to make the judiciary submissive to the government their Lordships have held up, as the protector of the Constitution, a beacon of hope for democracy and freedom.Let us not deny ourselves the protection of democracy and the rule of law to make ourselves vulnerable to violence and lawlessness. The power itself does not solve any problem, absolute power blinds one absolutely.It is understandable but painful to see the angry reactions of the persons in power to the judgement for protecting the independence of the justice system. We cannot be uncivilised not to know the need of impartial justice.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Cricket »

No fracture found on Mushfiqur's forearm


Bangladesh heaved a huge sigh of relief after an X-ray report revealed that Mushfiqur Rahim had no fracture on his forearm.Mushfiqur, considered as the most dependable batsman of the country, got hit on his right forearm during a batting practice session while facing a bouncer from pace bowler Mustafizur Rahman.He ...

International »

Saudi Crown Prince lashes out at arch-rival Iran over tanker attacks


AFP, Riyadh :Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman accused arch-rival Iran of attacks on oil tankers in a vital Gulf shipping channel, adding he "won't hesitate" to tackle any threats to the kingdom, according to an interview published on Sunday.Two tankers were struck by explosions on Thursday in the Gulf ...

Cricket »

More than just a game: India face Pakistan in World Cup battle royale


Virat Kohli will have history on his side when India take on arch-rivals Pakistan in a World Cup blockbuster on Sunday -- a clash that is always more than just a game of cricket.India cut off bilateral cricket ties with its neighbour after the 2008 Mumbai terror attacks, with authorities ...

Cricket »

Eoin Morgan downplays England's injury concerns


England captain Eoin Morgan said that his team is "not at panic stations", after he and Jason Roy left the field with discomfort during the game against West Indies in Southampton on Friday, 14 June.Both Roy and Morgan had left the field at different points during West Indies' innings and ...

International »

Iran President renews ultimatum over nuclear pact compliance


Reuters, Dushanbe :Iran will continue scaling back compliance with its nuclear deal commitments unless other signatories show "positive signals", the Iranian president told a meeting of Russian, Chinese and other Asian leaders in Tajikistan.Iran stopped complying in May with some commitments in a 2015 nuclear deal that was agreed with ...

Editorial »

Don't let successes go in vain


A total of 298 people were killed and 860 sustained injuries in road accidents across the country during the Eid-ul Fitr vacation. A report of Bangladesh Jatri Kallyan Samiti presented the statistics at a press conference at Dhaka Reporters' Unity on Saturday. It said the accidents took place within 13 ...

Entertainment »

Kareena to reunite with Aamir Khan for the Hindi remake of Forest Grump?


After Karan Johar's period drama, Takht and Homi Adajania's Angrezi Medium, Kareena Kapoor Khan has given her nod to another big project and it's one of the most awaited projects already. Thanks to the incredible popularity and credibility of its leading man, superstar Aamir Khan. Yes, after 3 Idiots (2009) ...

Editorial »

The tax-happy fat budget


THE government in the FY 2019-20 budget announcement set many promises including 8.2 percent GDP growth rate and bring down the inflation at 5.5 percent. In first look, we think the promises are over ambitious. The ever biggest budget of Tk 523,190 crore is a may appear as biggest mockery ...

City »

Bangabandhu Sangskritik Jote formed a human chain in front of the Jatiya Press Club on Friday greeting Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina and Finance Minister AHM Mostofa Kamal for presenting people-oriented budget.


.

International »

Iran has no intention to make or use nuclear weapons: Khamenei


Reuters, Tokyo :Iran has no intention of making or using nuclear weapons, Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei was quoted as saying on Thursday by Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe.Khamenei's comment, a reiteration of Iran's stance, comes at a time of increased US-Iranian tension, a year after Washington abandoned an ...

Entertainment »

Deepika Padukone tops the list of Most Gorgeous Women in the World by a magazine


A Global Icon, Deepika Padukone tops the list of Most Gorgeous Women in the World from Bollywood. Giving a definition to beauty, Observer Dawn wrote: “Beautiful women in the world have created a magic history through their work and other qualities.” They further added, “There is definitely more to beauty ...

Editorial »

ACC miserably failed to meet people's expectation


PRIME MINISTER Sheikh Hasina on Wednesday told Parliament that the public perception about many of the Anti-Corruption Commission employees being involved in corruption was not totally baseless. Responding to a supplementary question from ruling Awami League lawmaker Rafiqul Islam, leader of the House said that all the employees of the ...

Cricket »

Vaughan calls Finch the best captain at CWC19


Aaron Finch's captaincy has earned him the praise of Michael Vaughan, who hailed Finch's tactical nous, following Australia's 41-run victory against Pakistan in Taunton on Wednesday, 12 June.Vaughan hailed Finch's shrewd and brave decision-making, and called him the best captain at the ICC Men's Cricket World Cup (CWC) 2019 so ...

International »

Abe urges Iran to play 'constructive role' to prevent clash with US


AFP, Tehran :Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe urged Tehran to play a "constructive role" for Middle East peace Wednesday during a rare diplomatic mission to the Islamic republic aimed at defusing US-Iran tensions.Iran has been locked in a bitter standoff with the United States since US President Donald Trump withdrew ...

International »

US-Russia relations are getting ‘worse and worse’: Putin


Reuters, Moscow :President Vladimir Putin said relations between Moscow and Washington were getting worse and worse, noting in an interview published on Thursday that the current U.S. administration had imposed dozens of sanctions on Russia.Putin made his gloomy assessment ahead of a G20 summit in Japan later this month at ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news